16 Comments
User's avatar
Geronimo Collins's avatar

Doechii winning was the only highlight I cared to know (I didn’t watch). Your writing is a wonderful cohesion of culture, history, industry, and politics but for people who are voracious readers. If you would’ve given us 1000 more words, I would’ve continued reading without wincing.

As you pointed out, we are entering a post-rational era where even pushing through tragedy feels neither dignified nor honorable. Pardon the fatalism, but I thought about the band playing as the Titanic sunk as the best visual example of what I described.

Lastly, this quote is my favorite: “The Grammys should have ended the night Clive Davis’s pre-Grammy party continued at Los Angeles’s Beverly Hilton while Whitney Houston’s dead body was wheeled away at the same hotel.”

Expand full comment
Gioncarlo Valentine's avatar

Your writing makes me want to actually get up and throw hands—fighting and praise dancing! Brilliant as always. Loved the bit about Doechii especially because no matter how much I feel about the pageantry and performance of all of this rape culture and white supremacist bullshit, something in me still wanted to see her win. This shit is so entangled and embattled. Thank you for “getting it” and saying it as only you can.

Expand full comment
Harmony Holiday's avatar

Thank you for getting it. The imagery even she is forced to carry out is so very embattled I'd love to see her free from it too.

Expand full comment
Andrielle The Oracle's avatar

the way your words are well weighty, blows the mind. dragged bar for bar as though wading through a swamp of perishing celebrity culture. love your work.

Expand full comment
Harmony Holiday's avatar

thank you!!

Expand full comment
Jasmyne Gilbert's avatar

Hand to God, at least once a month one of your pieces takes my breath away. I mean utterly stuns me… How do you keep doing this 🙌🏽

Expand full comment
steve romagnoli's avatar

Baldwin's most fitting coda to your most excellent piece is a most merciless nail into the cross of song's crucifixion, the agony and slow death of amerikan music's demise.  yet jimmy b does offer the possibility of redemption and resurrection, i think, even if it is but a slim chance.

Expand full comment
Caroline Osella's avatar

Your analysis is icicle-accurate and your writing sits in the (very hard to pull off) space between poetry and analysis. Thanks so much for this piece. We need prophets and seers as we move into this moment of culminatory sickness. I'll be holding your words close and waiting patiently for more.

Expand full comment
o f's avatar

When I saw Sabrina Carpenter I knew the industry was cooked. American producers only tell Hollywood Golden Age jokes when they don't know where their paycheck is coming from

Expand full comment
Aren's avatar

brilliant analysis

Expand full comment
GS-z-14-1's avatar

My grade school teacher would have required a complete rewrite without the run-on sentences.

I say, rules can be bent to suit artistic intention, and your work is compositional genius.

Expand full comment
china moses's avatar

I don't know if anyone has written a better piece about the nonsensical form of this relic of a tradition. I am still wondering how and why they even had the ceremony. Seeing Doechii and Meshell win was absolutely worth it, but at what cost? Babyface being cut off Milton Nascimento not being allowed to sit with Esperanza, Beatles receiving another award….

Expand full comment
Harmony Holiday's avatar

So much blasphemy! Everything must change

Expand full comment
GS-z-14-1's avatar

In such times, public blasphemy is civic duty.

Expand full comment
Bev13's avatar

Well done

Expand full comment
Vince Roman's avatar

Thanks for the great read!

Expand full comment