Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sumire's avatar

Hello! I like the point of the article, but I wanted to point out how it feels a little condescending as a Pakistani to read that we “welcomed Onijah as a matriarch and spiritual guide” and that she boosted “the morale of Pakistani natives.” Though I’m sure it wasn’t intended that way, it perpetuates colonial narratives of us as a people who need (and are happy to welcome) a savior or a guide from the West—and honestly, it just doesn’t align with how people (at least those in my community whom I talked to about it) saw her. I think it’s totally possible to make the argument that drives the piece without positioning Pakistanis as the good-natured, willing subjects of empire (I’m thinking about how easy it is for an american to come to Pakistan and make demands of the government and people, while Pakistanis are the subject of immigration bans—even if Onijah never intended to act as such, americans act entitled to access other countries in such ways because of the structure of US empire). Again, I like the piece as a whole and I don’t believe there were any bad intentions—I just wanted to highlight one component of it :)

Expand full comment
juvenile delinquent's avatar

the internet has a morbid fascination with alleged “freak shows” just so that they can feel superior and pat themselves on the back for being “so cerebral.”

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts